The Wall Street Journal tells a fairy tale in which billionaires create wealth while workers, enslaved people, Indigenous nations, Black farmers, public institutions, and the Global South disappear from the ledger. This excavation restores the buried history beneath American fortunes: conquest, slavery, land theft, union-breaking, financial extraction, digital surveillance, and unequal exchange. The real divide is not between innovators and envious socialists, but between the masses who collectively produce social wealth and the minority whose property claims grant them command over it. The answer is organization—from the shop floor to the wider struggle for collective control over humanity’s abundance.